Plastic vs. metal backplate Alphacool (under LGA 1700)

Conclusion

For rather incomprehensible reasons, the cooling performance of the vast majority of AIO liquid coolers is degraded by the use of an unsuitable backplate. The backplate is usually undersized, made of plastic, and cannot exert optimal pressure on the processor. To give you an idea of how a “traditional” plastic backplate stacks up against a proper, steel one, we’ve prepared a comparison of the two.

Conclusion

The results of the metal backplate versus the plastic one clearly show that the plastic variant is really inadequate for more expensive coolers. When a cooler gets a bigger radiator, more pump flow, or more efficient fans, none of these (even in combination) may improve cooling performance as much as the higher pressure of a robust backplate.

See how small the differences are between the different liquid coolers in our tests and also, how big the difference in results can be for the same liquid cooler with different backplates. Our measurements did not achieve as significant a difference as Alphacool claims, but this does not negate their claims of a 13°C reduction in temperature with a metal backplate.

The above temperature drop is real, although although in our case it was at best “only” 7 °C (Too little? again let’s remember tests of CPU coolers, go through them to see what are the differences between the different models of liquid coolers). This is because Alphacool most likely used a custom loop for comparison, which has a significantly higher cooling capacity (TDP) than the Eisbaer Aurora we used for our tests. This is also evidenced by the fact that Alphacool talks about a 240W load in the context of their results.

At a similar load (~250 W) in our tests, the largest temperature difference due to backplate effects was not achieved. The latter was recorded at significantly lower loads. A load corresponding to 250 W is already out of the effective range of the Eisbaer Aurora 360 (and not only of it, but of most of its AIO alternatives) and it achieves the best results at a different, lower TDP.

After exceeding the most efficient range, the cooling performance of each and every cooler drops, sometimes quite dramatically. In this case, it wasn’t so terrible, and the Eisbaer Aurora 360 with a metal backplate still achieved temperatures four degrees Celsius lower temperatures than if you used a plastic backplate. In gaming load (12900K) at a power draw of about 100 W, the difference is greater – 7 °C.

However, the biggest temperature difference will be somewhere between 100–250 W (maybe even closer to 13 °C). But that would be for another article, which would deal with which cooler is most efficient at which load with which CPU, and where it starts to tip (and the progression takes an inefficient trend). But that’s a new topic in itself.

Anyway, the use of a metal backplate is important, and although it is ignored by the manufacturers of expensive liquid coolers, it needs to be vigorously pointed out. With a price of 7 euros (that’s how much the tested Alphacool Core backplate is sold for), it doesn’t make much sense to pay significantly higher amounts for other elements when such a simple (and cheap) thing as a solid backplate will do more work.

English translation and edit by Jozef Dudáš




  •  
  •  
  •  
Flattr this!

The armored Apex Stealth fans promise the “impossible”

Alphacool has unleashed the new Apex Stealth fans on the world, which attract attention for two things in particular. Firstly, the fact that they contain robust metal elements and secondly, the specifications. These seem to be literally incredible, and while we have no doubt that the efficiency of these fans will be top notch, it’s hard to find elements for which they should be “the best”, as the specs suggest. Read more “The armored Apex Stealth fans promise the “impossible”” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

Alphacool introduces the “Core” series of high-speed fans

Six new models, with the slowest capping at 2,000 rpm and the fastest up to 4,000 rpm. It’s a mix of 120 and 140-millimeter fans, where with the larger format Alphacool reached for differently modeled rotors. This is also with a view to ensuring that a fan this fast and relatively large can operate at all at reasonably low vibration. Among Alphacool’s new products is therefore a fan with more robust blades as well. Read more “Alphacool introduces the “Core” series of high-speed fans” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

Alphacool: Our new thermal paste is faster than stainless steel

Watch out, Alphacool has started aiming pretty high. In the specifications for the latest Apex thermal paste, it lists a thermal conductivity that it claims is not only above the best competing thermal pastes, but even outperforms some metals. Unless Alphacool is stretching reality, this is going to be an extremely effective formula. You won’t guess what its main ingredient is. Read more “Alphacool: Our new thermal paste is faster than stainless steel” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

One comment Add comment

  1. Excellent testing as always. Hopefully with the integrated backplate on AM5, more manufacturers will be forced to utilize proper metal backplates instead of flimsy custom ones.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *