To provide the best experiences, we and our partners use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us and our partners to process personal data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site and show (non-) personalized ads. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Click below to consent to the above or make granular choices. Your choices will be applied to this site only. You can change your settings at any time, including withdrawing your consent, by using the toggles on the Cookie Policy, or by clicking on the manage consent button at the bottom of the screen.
Technické uloženie alebo prístup sú nevyhnutne potrebné na legitímny účel umožnenia použitia konkrétnej služby, ktorú si účastník alebo používateľ výslovne vyžiadal, alebo na jediný účel vykonania prenosu komunikácie cez elektronickú komunikačnú sieť.
Technické uloženie alebo prístup je potrebný na legitímny účel ukladania preferencií, ktoré si účastník alebo používateľ nepožaduje.
Technické úložisko alebo prístup, ktorý sa používa výlučne na štatistické účely.
Technické úložisko alebo prístup, ktorý sa používa výlučne na anonymné štatistické účely. Bez predvolania, dobrovoľného plnenia zo strany vášho poskytovateľa internetových služieb alebo dodatočných záznamov od tretej strany, informácie uložené alebo získané len na tento účel sa zvyčajne nedajú použiť na vašu identifikáciu.
Technické úložisko alebo prístup sú potrebné na vytvorenie používateľských profilov na odosielanie reklamy alebo sledovanie používateľa na webovej stránke alebo na viacerých webových stránkach na podobné marketingové účely.
it seems even on Q mode it may get outside of the silent zone when pushed hard enough…
I know, I know, all the other cards are worse, but if even 3 of these fans struggle it means a lot about the power output of modern cards, doesn’t it?
What matters most is what a “quiet” graphics card means to each individual — it’s a pretty subjective thing.
At just under 700 RPM, it’s extremely quiet. At night, when everything is silent, you can hear it if you put your ear close to the card. From a typical distance of about a meter, even on an open test bench, I can’t hear it at all. But my hearing isn’t what it was twenty years ago.
However, considering the temperatures the card reaches, there’s still some headroom to lower the fan speed by adjusting the fan curve. Throughout the day, I’ll be running additional tests across the full fan-speed range in Cyberpunk and will add line charts of clock speeds and temperatures to the article.
Without V-Sync, the coil whine is still more noticeable under load than the fans themselves—even in Q-Mode—though it’s quieter than on other cards with the same performance. The tougher part might be keeping the CPU just as quiet and getting the heat out of the case without adding noise.
I haven’t precisely tuned G2 fans yet, but 700RPM would be somewhere in the range of upper limit, for G1 that was around 670, the Q profile seems to be willing to push above that if heated enough instead of limiting the heat to ensure fans won’t spin up, requiring manual tuning
which to be fair is expected of Noctua products as they don’t tune for absolute silence as general audience expects much less, but their high quality allows to achieve it with some extra effort
the coil whine though absolutely shouldn’t be there, that’s something most companies seem to neglect the most, I know it’s hard to control and there’s a ton of variance between specific items, but at this price point it’s unexcusable
I’d say even more: it’s unexcusable at any price point that isn’t explicitly cheapened cutting all costs for the last pennies, unfortunately… getting components and accessories that don’t suffer from that is nearly impossible, like… I’m not gonna try dozens of different units of a monitor to pick the one with least whine, right?
At least when it comes to temperatures shown in the monitoring, they’re fine—even at minimum fan speeds.
https://www.hwcooling.net/en/asus-geforce-rtx-5080-noctua-oc-ed-16gb-review-silent-monster/20/
Does GPU watercooling even make sense anymore? The graphics cards are becoming quieter and cooler with each new generation, even without deshrouding.
Yes, some cards are now quiet enough that the main source of noise is elsewhere. For example, in my test rig I often find the CPU cooler is louder, because I have the fan curve set to ramp up whenever any core goes over 80 °C.
It would be more appropriate to say that it depends on the circumstances. The key difference is that liquid cooling moves the GPU’s heat to a radiator mounted away from the card, making exhausting hot air easier when the radiator is properly positioned in the case. With an air cooler, you still need to figure out exhausting the heat from the case.
It’s a bit different from processors. With a CPU, the priority is cooling a small area—the CPU itself and the surrounding VRM (voltage regulation modules).
A good block on GPU usually reduces hotspots on the die and VRAM, but it can worsen cooling of the other components. But on a graphics card, there are many hot parts spread across the entire PCB. That’s why having fans directly over the hot zones usually works best. Full-cover blocks solve the problem of cooling components, but this is an expensive and complicated solution. If, instead, the manufacturer uses a cheaper AIO cooler on the GPU and a card-mounted fan to cool the other components, it usually isn’t dead silent. The pump can also be noisy unless the manufacturer keeps it under control.
Air cooling, in contrast, is simpler, cheaper, and generally more reliable. When paired with a large heatsink with enough surface area, it can be a very competitive option.
Personally, I prefer air cooling for its ease of use, consistent long-term performance, lower risk of failure and its reliability.
Thank you for the info.
I’m building a PC with Ryzen 9 9950X and RTX 5070 Ti. The CPU is cooled by a custom liquid loop with one 420mm and one 280mm radiator. I just can’t decide whether to include the GPU in the loop. The full cover waterblock by Bykski costs about $100.
Since a water cooled graphics card does not heat up other components, such as SSD, RAM, chipset, etc, I’ll probably go with the waterblock. My radiator space should be enough for that.
There’s actually a true specialist in our country who focuses on fully liquid-cooled builds. I’ll write to Gabo (from TichéPC) — you might get a response full of hands-on experience. 🙂