MSI MEG Silent Gale P12: A dominant all-rounder for a price

Cooling, Extra tests, Fans | | Ľubomír Samák

Evaluation

While the Silent Gale P12 isn’t the first fan in MSI’s lineup (like the Strix XF120 from Asus), it beats anything previous from the company by a mile. This is by the efficiency of the rotor, which is suitable for radiators as well as for a case, but also by the overall robust design. There’s a big, powerful but quiet motor, and you won’t even know about the hydrodynamic bearings.

Evaluation

The application possibilities of the MSI MEG Silent Gale P12 are exceptionally broad. What does this mean? Firstly, that in addition to the wide speed range (187~1905 rpm) at low PWM intensity, this fan can also run in a passive mode. But that’s just the basics, the important thing is, of course, efficiency and sound. And when the headline talked about versatility, it was because of the fact that the Silent Gale P12 delivers balanced performance on both radiators and grilles within a computer case.

Compared to the Strix XF120, the Strix XF120 is more efficient and at a low noise level (31 dBA) very significantly so. This is the level at which system fans in well-optimised computers operate. Coexisting with a nylon dust filter, it’s additionally completely different music than the fans from the big comparison test. But since it is not a cheap fan, the Silent Gale P12 definitely needs all this.The MSI fan also has a significantly high airflow and also pressure through radiators, so it is without a doubt suitable for this use. The only thing it slightly lags behind the Strix XF120 in is static pressure on radiators at higher noise levels. However, at lower (more acceptable for quiet PCs) levels, it’s all in control of the Silent Gale P12.

It is also worth praising the fact that MSI does not mislead in the specifications. The reported airflow overlaps with our measurements. The specified static pressure values differ more significantly from our measurements, but these are still not dramatic differences. We measured 1.89 mm H2O and the parameters state 2.21 mm H2O. It’s also due to the fact that neither of our samples can do 2000 rpm. The reality is 1900 rpm and it’s questionable whether some pieces will even make it to the paper maximum at 12 PWM controller power. Most of the time, fans are a hair faster, here the opposite is true. But you’ll probably just wave your hand over this one, because either way you’ll be tuning the speed to lower noise levels. And those are good to break down to the individual frequency level.

The sound is clean, aerodynamic (no mechanical components from the bearings and motor), we’ve already mentioned that. However, it is important to add that high (more unpleasant) frequencies are successfully avoided by the Silent Gale P12 and even at high (~1590) speeds it stays in the spectrum of deeper tones. That is, as long as he has no obstacle in front of it. It’s worse with a plastic dust filter, with it, the fan already hisses clearly at 5-7.5 kHz. However, this is not a shortcoming of the Silent Gale, and it applies to other fans as well (including those from Noctua), and in the future it will be interesting to see if any of the models show lower frequencies in this situation.

The more pronounced frequencies with the hexagonal grille are also below 2 kHz (i.e. quite pleasant). So once again we come back to the fact that the MSI fan is really suitable for use in a case as well. Vibrations are, moreover, negligible, so it won’t rattle even on the thinner sheet metal that has become a symbol of contemporary manufacturing. Low vibration intensity or low friction is also associated with low power draw (0.22-1.23 W). However, the motor power is high (4.31 W), which is only good.

On the other hand the scores forairflow per euro and static pressure pre euro are both lacking. The Silent Gale P12 is expensive and certainly more expensive than it would benefit from compared to the Noctua NF-A12x25 PWM chomax.black, compared to which it only has the benefit of the motor shutting down at low speeds. It’s admittedly a harsh statement for an otherwise good fan, but it would probably also be naive to expect Noctua to pull the short end of the stick in key features, it certainly doesn’t. The Silent Gale P12 will therefore have a tough life despite the fact that there is almost nothing to fault it for. But if you come across it at a sale, don’t hesitate for a second.

English translation and edit by Jozef Dudáš


  •  
  •  
  •  
Back to: MSI MEG Silent Gale P12 in detail
Flattr this!

Related articles

In the works: Trilogy of different Arctic P14 variant tests

Cooling, Fans, Preview | | Ľubomír Samák

Slowly but surely, the Arctic P14 fan tests are coming up. In a short time sequence we will analyze all models that differ from each other more than the color design. After testing the base model, we’ll look at how the use of ball bearings (instead of fluid bearings) affects the results, culminating with the P14 Max framed impeller. That this fan must be the most efficient? Not necessarily. Read more “In the works: Trilogy of different Arctic P14 variant tests” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

BeQuiet! put all their modern fans in white

Cooling, Fans, News | | Ľubomír Samák

Both 120 and 140 mm BeQuiet! fans from the Silent Wings (Pro) 4 and Pure Wings 3 series are now available in an all-white design. So both more expensive and cheaper fans, which have in common a very high airflow per unit of noise. Across the entire price spectrum, you are dealing with some of the most efficient fans you can buy for computers. And not just among the white ones. Read more “BeQuiet! put all their modern fans in white” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

New Arctic P14 Max: Anti-vibration and high speed

Cooling, Fans, News | | Ľubomír Samák

Those interested in 140mm fans have reason to rejoice. After the P12 Max, Arctic is also releasing the P14 Max, which is one size larger. These stick to the already established features, such as a significant speed increase, but also probably a noise reduction even at low speeds. By all accounts, these should be universal fans that will be efficient across the entire speed spectrum, and on all types of obstacles. Read more “New Arctic P14 Max: Anti-vibration and high speed” »

  •  
  •  
  •  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *